• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

Polykleitos Spear Bearer Analysis Essay

The Doryphoros

  • Length: 346 words (1 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - More ↓
The Doryphoros

Description

This stone sculpture is a naked human-like figure standing six feet tall. The body is in chiasmos stance with the left leg slightly bent and the left foot slightly behind the right. The head is turned slightly downward and to the right, and its size is approximately 1/6 of the body. The hair is cropped closely to the head with no part. The body has a defined musculature, however the forearms appear to be missing. There is an object behind and to the right of the right leg that is about 2 feet tall and 10 inches wide.

Formal Analysis

This sculpture seems to epitomize the ideal male human form. All of the body parts seem perfectly proportioned and the muscles are beautifully defined as if the image were of an athlete. The image is youthful with a calm demeanor. The right missing forearm looks as if it used to be resting at his side, while the left elbow was probably at a 90 degree angle, with the hand holding something. The slight bend in the left leg gives the impression of movement, as if the image was frozen while walking. The counterpoised stance adds an air of nobility to the "man".

Historical Analysis

The sculpture is a Roman copy of the original Greek bronze made by artist Polykleitos in 450BC. It is recorded that he made the Doryphoros as an example of perfect proportion. He wrote a book to accompany the statue called, "The Cannon of Proportion, " and countless artists copied the statue because of its perfection. This regal figure was named Doryphoros (Greek for "spearbearer") because it originally held a long spear in its left hand.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Doryphoros." 123HelpMe.com. 11 Mar 2018
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=43819>.

LengthColor Rating 
Essay about Doryphoros - Doryphoros by Polykleitos was originally a Greek bronze made around 450-40B.C. The only way we can see it today is through the Roman marble copies (which is common of many Greek statues.) Some supports had to be added for the change in material, resulting in the addition of the form resembling a tree trunk, the support on the left foot, and the small bar bridging the gap between his right wrist and hip. Doryphoros was originally holding a spear in his left hand; appropriate, given that his name means, literally, “spear-bearer.” The sculpture is a well-known and early example of classical Greek contrapposto (the shifting of weight onto one leg and off-axis shoulders and arms.) One leg nearly...   [tags: Greek Art]788 words
(2.3 pages)
Better Essays[preview]
Kroisos vs Doryphoros Essay - Kroisos vs Doryphoros The difference between an archaic statue such as Kroisos (fig. 5-11) and a classical statue such as Doryphoros (fig. 5-42) may not seem very great in a single glance. In fact, you may not notice any differences in that one glance. Yet, if you were to look at them closely, you can see that these two statues actually have very little in common. The first glance you’ve taken at those two statues, you just see a man standing there. They are not doing anything in particular, just standing there....   [tags: Essays Papers]556 words
(1.6 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Andrew Stewart and the Meaning Behind the Two Pieces, Doryphoros (Spearbearer) and Aphrodite of Knidos - The author talks about the meaning behind the two pieces, Doryphoros (Spearbearer) and Aphrodite of Knidos. He begins by going into the basic history of what men and women at the time were expected to do during their short lived lives. He paired these two pieces because of the masculinity and femininity that divides and unites the two classical Greek sculptures. Stewart talks about genders and the gender roles that were expected of men and women at the time the artwork was made in ancient Greece....   [tags: Sculptures, Classical]1230 words
(3.5 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Before Our Eyes: The Collections of The Minneapolis Institute of Art Essay - The Minneapolis Institute of Art has many beautiful collections. The evening class that we art students attended proved to be informative as well as relaxing. The class covered looking at what we had recently studied in the first section. The ancient near east, Egyptian, Greek, Roman, Etruscan and Aegean art were the subjects of our evening. Everyone was able to see the Doryphorus, which was accented by decorative streamers hanging from the ceiling. We were also able to observe pieces that were similar to ones studied....   [tags: Art]
:: 5 Works Cited
845 words
(2.4 pages)
Good Essays[preview]
Art and History Displayed at the Pompeii Exhibition at LACMA Essay - The Pompeii exhibition at LACMA was an astounding visualization of history. The exhibition provided all sorts of objects; from sculptures, glass figures, painted art, and more. These art pieces specify the kind of life that was taking place in the Bay of Naples during the second century. As we know the cities around the Bay of Naples, which include Pompeii and Herculaneum, became tourist attractions when the cities were excavated after they were buried from the volcanic eruption of Mount Vesuvius....   [tags: World History, Art]829 words
(2.4 pages)
Better Essays[preview]
Art and Architectural History Essay - 1) The Parthenon was built to replace earlier temples of Athena which were famous during that period of time. The structure of the Parthenon consists of a rectangular floor with a series of low steps on every side, and a colonnade of columns extended around the entire construction. It has more than one entrance in which each one has an addition of six columns in the front. The Parthenon has two large rooms inside. The larger of the two interior rooms named ‘’The Naos’’, has a statue inside. The smaller room was practically used to save treasures....   [tags: Parthenon, Roman style]876 words
(2.5 pages)
Better Essays[preview]
The Human Body in Ancient Greek Sculptures Essay example - The Human Body in Ancient Greek Sculptures The primary focus of ancient Greek sculptures was that of the human body. Almost all Greek sculptures are of nude subjects. As the first society to focus on nude subjects, Greek sculptors attempted to "depict man in what they believed was the image of the gods and so would come to celebrate the body by striving for verisimilitude or true – likeness (realism and naturalism!)."(Riffert) Not only did the Greeks celebrate the human form in their art but also in everyday life....   [tags: Art History Essays]
:: 4 Works Cited
1006 words
(2.9 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Comparing Roman and Greek Art Essay - Comparing Roman and Greek Art Throughout history art has consistently reflected the cultural values and social structures of individual civilizations. Ancient art serves as a useful tool to help historians decipher some important aspects of ancient culture. From art we can determine the basic moral and philosophical beliefs of many ancient societies. The differences in arts purpose in Greece and Rome, for example, show us the fundamental differences in each culture's political and moral system....   [tags: Ancient Rome Greece History Arts]
:: 1 Works Cited
1184 words
(3.4 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]
Comparisons of Art Essays - Comparisons of Art In the Egyptian era there were many art forms that were done and sculpted. Seated Scribe is one of these Egyptians sculptures. It was done in 2400 B.C.E and was done in limestone by subtractive sculpting. The colors that are used in this sculpture are very plain and bland. You can notice that the color is wearing away at the sculpture because there are blotches where the paint has started to chip away. The sculpture is physically accurate of a middle-aged man because you can see the definition of the extra fat on his body and you can tell that he has some intelligence because of the way that he is presenting himself and that he is ready to write....   [tags: essays papers]1950 words
(5.6 pages)
Strong Essays[preview]

Related Searches

Left Foot         Ancient Greeks         Left Hand         Greek Culture         Historical Analysis         Formal Analysis         Spear         Calm         Feet         Looks        




The statue epitomized the Greek human ideal -- the athletic body is perfect in proportion and muscle, and the face is classically handsome as well. The Ancient Greeks believed that goodness and beauty went hand in hand. A sound mind equalled a sound body. The Greek culture sought after this perfection for themselves not only because it was attractive but also "moral" -- Doryphoros was their example.



Glossary:

Black Figure Style: a style of painted pot from the Archaic Period (600–480 BCE) in which figures and forms are created through the application of black slip before firing.

Contrapposto: posing of the human figure in which one part is turned in opposition to another part, typically with the weight of the body being thrown to one foot to create a counterbalance of the body about its central axis.

Geometric Style: a style of painted pot from the Geometric Period (900–700 BCE) dominated by abstract motifs (e.g. the meander pattern) and animals conveyed through black slip.

Humanism: an ideological or philosophical approach that stresses the importance of the human being, rather than divine or celestial forces, and the human being’s potential for achievement or greatness in all things.

Kore: Greek for “young woman”; statuary type depicting a young woman.

Kouros: Greek for “young man”; statuary type depicting a young man.

Krater: a large vessel used by the ancient Greeks to mix wine with water; also sometimes used as male funerary markers.

Red Figure Style: a style of painted pot from the Archaic Period (600–480 BCE) in which figures and forms are created through the absence of black slip, allowing the red of the terracotta to come through for greater design detail and finesse; appeared late sixth century BCE.

Symmetria: symmetry, including a sense of proportion and balance, as achieved by contrapposto poses.

White Ground Style: a style of painted pot from the Archaic Period (600–480 BCE) in which figures and forms are painted on white clay pot, allowing for greater detail and polychromy; also appeared late sixth century BCE.

 

From the rise of ancient Greek art around 800 BCE to its decline during the reign of Alexander the Great in the fourth century BCE, the artists of this period revolutionized the treatment of the human form. Ushered in with the early Geometric Period, which continued past conventions of stylized and abstracted forms, the rapid advancement of figural treatment and proportion became over the following centuries the hallmark of ancient Greek art and the feature most emulated by artists of both the subsequent Roman Empire and the Renaissance centuries later.

One important impetus for the development of anatomical proportions in Greek art was the emergence of humanism, an ideological or philosophical approach that stresses the importance of the human being, rather than divine or celestial forces. Humanism focuses on human experience and naturalistic perspectives, and emphasizes the human being’s potential for achievement or greatness in all things.

Here are some key works, organized by time period, that can be used to illustrate the progression of Greek artists rendering the human form during a one-hour-fifteen-minute class:

Timeline:
Geometric Period (800–700 BCE)
Orientalizing Period (700–600 BCE)
Archaic Period (600–480 BCE)
Early Classical Period (480–450 BCE)
High Classical Period (450–420 BCE)
Late Classical Period (420–323 BCE)
Hellenistic Period (323–31 BCE)

  • Funerary Krater, Dipylon Cemetery, c. 760 BCE, Geometric, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York
  • Mantiklos Apollo, Greece, c. 700–680 BCE, Orientalizing, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston
  • Exekias, Achilles and Ajax Playing Dice, c. 530 BCE, Archaic, Vatican Museums, Rome
  • Euphronios, Death of a Sarpedon Krater, 515 BCE, Archaic, National Etruscan Museum, Rome
  • Phiale Painter, Hermes Bringing the Infant Dionysos to Papposilenos, c. 440–435 BCE, Archaic, Vatican Museums, Rome
  • Statue of a Kouros, c. 580 BCE, Archaic, Metropolitan Museum of Art
  • Kroisos Kouros, Anavysos, c. 530 BCE, Archaic, 76 inches high, National Archaeological Museum, Athens
  • Kritios Boy, 480 BCE, Early Classical, 34 inches high, Acropolis Museum
  • Dying Warrior, Temple of Aphaia, West, 500–490 BCE (vs. East Pediment, 490–480 BCE), Glyptothek, Munich
  • Polykleitos, Doryphoros (Spear Bearer), Roman copy of a Greek original from 440 BCE, High Classical, Archaeological Museum of Naples
  • Praxiteles, Hermes and the Infant Dionysos, Roman copy of a Greek original from c. 340 BCE, Late Classical, Louvre Museum, Paris
  • Gallic Chieftain Killing Himself and His Wife, Roman copy of a Greek original from c. 320–220 BCE, Hellenistic, Palazzo Altemps, Rome
  • Defeated Boxer, c. 100–50 BCE, Hellenistic, Palazzo Massimo alle Terme, Rome

The Funerary Krater from the Dipylon Cemetery bears the essential hallmarks of the early Geometric Period, which gets its name from the repeated use of geometric patterns and motifs during this time. Here, clearly divided registers, or levels, of decoration alternate between different abstract geometric designs, including the meander pattern seen in the upper lip of the pot. The belly of the krater is decorated with two larger registers that are separated by geometric patterns and filled with a stylized representation of a funeral procession. The upper register reveals the deceased individual, laid out rigidly across a funerary bier, and to either side appear abstract female forms, whose crossed arms overhead are meant to signal their mourning. The lower register reveals a procession of soldiers with their horses, presenting additional examples of the tendency toward abstracted figures. The soldiers, for example, appear as if they are shields with limbs, while the chariot horses are melded into one horse-like shape with a multitude of legs.

This abstraction of form continued into the Orientalizing Period, as illustrated by the Mantiklos Apollo. Earning this name from the inscription across his thighs that reads: “Mantiklos donated me as a tithe to the far shooter, the bearer of the Silver Bow. You, Phoebus (Apollo) give me something pleasing in return,” this small bronze cast votive reveals stylized treatment of the human form similar to that of the Dipylon krater, with an inverted triangular torso, elongated neck, and oblong face.

Moving into the Archaic Period, one witnesses a profusion of painted pottery. These ceramic pieces reflect the talents of Greek painters for rendering figural naturalism. The skill required for these pieces is attested to by the fact that artists signed many of the pieces they painted. The first style to emerge was known as Black Figure Style pottery, so-called because figures appear through the application and subsequent kiln oxidation of applied silica slip. Exekias’ Achilles and Ajax Playing Dice illustrates this style of pot. Comparing this to the Dipylon funerary krater, one can see that the repeated geometric patterns and abstracted figures are here replaced with a narrative reduced to one central register and a clearer articulation of figures and compositional elements. It is as if Ezekias has caught Achilles and Ajax in a heated moment of the game, both hunched over the board in observation.

The same feeling can be attained from Red Figure Style pottery, as illustrated by Euphronios’ Death of Sarpedon Krater. Here figures are formed through the absence of the silica slip, with the advantage of allowing more intricate details within the composition. In the main narrative panel of the Death of Sarpedon Krater, for example, Euphronios’ mastery of the red figure technique allowed him to delineate musculature and bleeding wounds, details that add to the dramatic scene, wherein Sarpedon, defeated by the spear of Patroclus during the Trojan War, is carried off the battlefield by Sleep and Death.

The White Ground technique, the last of the three styles of Greek painted pottery, carried the field forward by introducing the element of polychromy, or multi-colored forms. This style, as illustrated in the Phiale Painter’s Hermes Bringing the Infant Dionysos to Papposilenos, involved painting narrative scenes in many colors on a white clay pot. The result, similar to a painting on a canvas, was imagery as intricate as seen in Red and Black Figure pots, but here the addition of vibrant color brings these stories to life.

Also during the Archaic Period, we find that artists become exponentially more adept at conjuring the naturalism of the human body. Statue of a Kouros reveals efforts, for example, to better convey the musculature of a male figure, with incised lines used to delineate abdominal and thigh muscles. This kouros, or “young man,” also exhibits greater facial expression, illustrating the tight, mannequin-like expression known as the “archaic smile,” a common feature of the sculpture of this period.

Compare the Metropolitan’s Statue of a Kouros to the Kroisos Kouros, carved forty years later, and you can get a sense of how quickly artists innovated their approach to the figure. While the Kroisos Kouros figure maintains the archaic smile, mat-like layer of braided hair, and rigid stance similar to the Metropolitan’s kouros, the kouros from Anavysos shows great advances in the Greeks’ understanding of anatomy and musculature. Contoured muscles have replaced incised lines, and the overall girth of the thighs and torso bring us even closer to a naturalistic human figure.

The Kritios Boy reflects the next step in this evolution during the transition to the Early Classical Period, commenced with the victory of the Greeks over Persian invaders and considered, along with the High Classical Period, the peak years of ancient Greek civilization. Though the Kritios Boy’s face is still relatively expressionless, the archaic smile is gone, and the carved eyes, which originally would have had inlaid stone, suggest a step toward imbuing the figure with personality. Also improved is the artist’s understanding of musculature, so much so that the sculpture gives a sense of the tactility of its flesh. What is most striking about this figure, however, is the effort to capture the naturalistic stance of contrapposto, wherein the shoulders shift opposite to the pelvis, allowing the figural weight to rest on one leg while the other bends slightly.

The development of naturalism was central to the transition from the Archaic to the Early Classical Periods, as demonstrated by a visual analysis of the Western Pediment Dying Warrior (500–490 BCE) and Eastern Pediment Dying Warrior (490–480 BCE) from the Temple of Aphaia at Aegina. Though these two figures were completed within a decade of each other, they reveal this essential transition. The Western Pediment Dying Warrior maintains the same characteristics of his Archaic predecessors (archaic smile, mannequin-like appearance) while revealing the limitations of this approach to sculptural representation. This figure is intended to be in the throes of death as he grips at the arrow that has pierced his chest; however, his expressionless face and rigid smile do not connote such agony. Added to this missing emotional context is the awkward position in which this warrior’s body has been folded. He balances on one hip while jauntily crossing his leg, a position difficult for anyone to assume, let alone a dying soldier. His Eastern Pediment Warrior counterpart, however, reveals a greater sense of naturalism not only in pose but also in expression.

The Greek sculptor Polykleitos was known for his perfection of the contrapposto stance in conjunction with his writing of the Canon, one of the most influential known ancient treatises on art. In this text, Polykleitos advocates for sculptural symmetria, which basically means that all parts of the sculpture should be designed in perfect proportion to each other. This principle is demonstrated in his Doryphoros (Spear Bearer), particularly in the counterbalance of the figure’s shoulders to his hips. With his weight resting on his right foot, this figure’s left leg is bent and his left foot is extended behind him, as if the spear bearer has been caught mid-stride. While this positioning of the legs causes the spear bearer’s left hip to dip downward, Polykleitos compensates for this by adjusting his left shoulder upward. This counterbalancing allows for the symmetria of the sculpture and thus fits Polykleitos’s canon for beauty. (A great clip illustrating Polykleitos’s canon, excerpted from the Nigel Spivey series mentioned below, can be found here.)

If Greek art of the High Classical Period is characterized by the refined idealism of the Doryphoros, the subsequent Late Classical Period, illustrated through sculptures such as Praxiteles’s Hermes and the Infant Dionysos, captures the period’s burgeoning interest in a more human approach to artistic depictions. This shift came in part due to the changing political atmosphere in Greece, where the relative calm of the preceding century had been replaced in the fourth century by upheaval and uncertainty. Most notable in this shift was the installation of Alexander the Great, whose father had gained control of Greek territories around 338 BCE yet met with death only two years later. While Alexander the Great’s military campaigns expanded Greece’s control to unprecedented borders, the atmosphere of unrest initiated artistic shifts.

In Hermes and the Infant Dionysos we see the figure of Hermes adopting a softened contrapposto stance as he cradles the infant Dionysos in the crook of his arm. Hermes’s gaze is gentler than that seen in Polykleitos’s Doryphoros, and his right arm would have once playfully held a bunch of grapes. In sum, the interaction seen here seems not the exchange between two gods but rather that between a caregiver and child, stressing the human qualities of these previously idealized deities.

The death of Alexander the Great in 323 BCE resulted in the division of his expansive empire among his top generals and signaled another artistic revolution as artists explored more novel means of expression. Building on the humanist qualities of Late Classical art, Hellenistic art emphasized emotion, drama, and theatricality. This was particularly apparent in those works reserved for military monuments, such as the Gallic Chieftain Killing Himself and His Wife. Originally part of a sculptural group erected on the acropolis of the kingdom of Pergamon, near present-day Bergama, Turkey, this dramatic grouping was intended to reinforce Pergamene victory over the Gauls while also expressing reverence for their nobility in defeat.

Here the Gallic chieftain stands poised to drive his sword into his own chest, the tip of his blade already piercing his skin and causing rivulets of blood below. He is depicted just after having killed his wife, whose body hangs limp next to him. His powerful pose, implying that death is more amenable than capture, provides a strong contrast to that of his wife’s lifeless body, and when observing this sculpture in the round it is as if you can envision what will happen next.

While Gallic Chieftain Killing Himself and His Wife conveys this strong sense of drama and theatricality, other sculptures from the Hellenistic Period offer greater subtlety of emotion. Such is illustrated by works like the bronze Defeated Boxer. Depicting a boxer who has presumably just lost a fight, this figure expresses a sense of total defeat, with hunched shoulders and a pitiful expression on his face. Thus, while not as immediately dramatic as works such as the Gallic Chieftain, in comparison the Defeated Boxer illustrates the truly remarkable range of emotional expression that Hellenistic sculptors were able to achieve.

One thought on “Polykleitos Spear Bearer Analysis Essay

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *